ConCourt throws out High Court ruling that sought to widen abortion access

by | Oct 17, 2026 | Crime & Court | 0 comments

Tafadzwa Nyikadzino

The Constitutional Court has thrown out a High Court ruling that sought to widen access to lawful abortion, declining to confirm declarations that key provisions of the Termination of Pregnancy Act were unconstitutional.

In a judgment delivered on Wednesday by Justice Bharat Patel, the seven-member bench set aside the High Court judgment after finding it had failed to conduct the full constitutional analysis required by law.

The case was brought by the Community Working Group on Health and human rights activist Nyasha Batitsa, who challenged section 4(a) of the Act for excluding mental health as a ground for lawful termination, arguing it discriminates against women with severe psychiatric conditions.

They also challenged the Act’s definition of “unlawful intercourse” for failing to cover pregnancies arising from sexual conduct criminalised under the Mental Health Act.

Justice Patel held that a finding that legislation limits a constitutional right does not automatically render it unconstitutional.

“A finding that the impugned legislation limits a constitutional right does not, without more, render that legislation unconstitutional,” he said, stressing the need to apply the limitation test under section 86(2) of the Constitution.

The Court refused to confirm the declarations of invalidity and set aside the High Court judgment, with no order as to costs.

The ruling leaves the substantive question of whether mental health should independently qualify as a ground for lawful termination without a final determination in these proceedings.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Features

Opinions